Evaluating Importers Like an Expert: A Practical Evaluation Manual

Understanding the requirements for evaluating an importer is just the first step in the complex world of international trade. But did you know that many of these transactions fail not due to a lack of regulatory knowledge, but because of inadequate assessment of trading partners?  

In our experience, the success of a transaction depends fundamentally on two factors: the profitability of the product and the right choice of importer. Additionally, to determine if a product is profitable, we need to analyze market demand, acquisition costs, and profit margins.  

Therefore, before embarking on any operation, we must thoroughly verify the importer's payment capacity. This evaluation includes reviewing customs import documents and compliance history. First and foremost, it is essential to confirm that the importer is established in the EU and registered for VAT—basic requirements for conducting import activities.  

Define the Ideal Importer Profile

Selecting the right importer is a decision of critical strategic importance for any foreign trade operation. At the end of the day, in a foreign country, our company will be only as good as our importer or distributor. For this reason, identifying the ideal profile is crucial to ensuring the success and continuity of commercial operations.  

Type of Company and Import Experience

When evaluating a potential importer, we must pay special attention to their track record and stability. The company’s longevity and experience are key indicators of their market knowledge and ability to handle the challenges of international trade. A company with more experience will generally have better connections with distribution channels and deeper knowledge of local customs procedures.  

Company size and corporate culture are also determining factors. The largest importer is not always the best fit for our products. In some cases, a specialized mid-sized company may offer greater dedication and focus than a large conglomerate. What matters is compatibility between our business philosophy and the importer’s.  

Another fundamental aspect to consider is their prior experience with products similar to ours, especially if they originate from the same country. This prior knowledge greatly facilitates adaptation and marketing processes. Additionally, their willingness and availability to provide information about their operations and commercial results are good indicators of transparency and commitment to the business relationship.  

Sectors They Operate In

The importer’s commercial activities and product range must align with our specific sector. An importer specialized in the same sector will have better knowledge of the target market, appropriate distribution channels, and existing competition.  

Importers can be classified into three main categories based on their commercial objectives:  

1. Input Optimizers: Companies that source optimal inputs from different countries to direct them to their internationally distributed production points.  
2. Opportunists: Businesses that identify products with potential to import and sell profitably to local clients.  
3. Arbitrage Seekers: Those looking for higher profitability at lower costs, prioritizing quality at the lowest price.  

We should also verify whether the importer is registered in specific sectoral registries—especially relevant when our products belong to regulated sectors like food, chemicals, or textiles. In many countries, including Mexico, customs authorities maintain specific registries for importers in regulated sectors, allowing only authorized companies to import certain products.  

Volume of Operations and Logistics Capacity

The importer’s purchasing and financing capacity determines the scale of our commercial operations. To evaluate this properly, it is important to know their volume of operations, defined as the total value of goods delivered and services rendered during the calendar year, including exempt transactions.  

In Spain, for example, the volume of operations is regulated under Article 121 of the VAT Law (37/1992) and determines many fiscal and commercial obligations. An importer with an adequate volume of operations will have greater stability and capacity to manage varying quantities of goods.  

Logistics capacity is another essential factor. A good importer must have the necessary infrastructure to:  

• Receive goods properly  
• Store them under optimal conditions  
• Manage inventory efficiently  
• Distribute through appropriate channels  
• Provide quality pre- and post-sales service  

Logistical import needs include services like planning, labeling, transportation, warehousing, handling, packaging, and customs management. Therefore, when evaluating the ideal profile, we must verify that the importer has these resources or maintains strategic alliances with specialized logistics operators.  

In conclusion, defining the ideal importer profile requires a multidimensional analysis that considers not only their experience and sectors of operation but also their financial and logistical capacity. Though labor-intensive, this evaluation is a fundamental step to minimize risks and maximize the chances of success in our import operations.  

Analyze the Market and Product Profitability

Market analysis is one of the foundational pillars before initiating any import operation. Beyond knowing the requirements to import into Spain, we must ensure that the product we plan to bring is truly profitable and has sufficient demand in the local market.  

Is the Product You Want to Import Profitable?

Profitability is the decisive factor that will determine the success or failure of our transaction. To evaluate it correctly, we need to analyze various factors that directly impact the financial viability of our operations.  

First, we must conduct a detailed analysis of all involved costs, including:  

• Product purchase price  
• International transportation costs  
• Tariffs and customs duties  
• Local storage and distribution costs  
• Administrative and management expenses  

It is crucial to assess whether the resulting net profit margin will be enough to cover all these costs and generate benefits. Profitability is not static, so we must anticipate potential fluctuations in material costs, exchange rate changes, and variations in market demand.  

A study conducted in Ecuador showed that to determine if a product is profitable to import, a full financial analysis must be performed, examining costs, sale prices, margins, and inventory turnover. In this study, demand analysis revealed that 68% of respondents engaged in outdoor activities, and 72.4% would be willing to buy specialized clothing for these activities.  

Local Demand and Market Trends

Understanding local demand is essential to determine if there is a market for our product. Online trend analysis tools like Google Trends are excellent for gauging a product’s popularity over time.  

However, it is advisable to complement this analysis with professional market studies. Spain’s Network of Economic and Commercial Offices abroad offers in-depth analyses of specific sectors or product markets considered of potential interest to Spanish companies.  

These studies provide high-value insights through:  

• Interviews with market companies and distributors  
• Inspections at points of sale  
• Identification of real opportunities for Spanish offerings  

Additionally, it is important to consider local consumption trends. For example, in Mallorca, nine out of ten consumed fish come from outside the Balearic Islands. This type of data reveals opportunities for importers but also trends toward more local and sustainable consumption.  

On the other hand, an interesting phenomenon to consider is that in some countries, when local production can meet demand, imports may be halted to protect local proximity and quality. This is a relevant factor when evaluating demand seasonality.  

Inventory Turnover Evaluation

Inventory turnover is a key indicator that helps us determine if a product will sell well in the market. This index measures how often inventory is depleted and replenished over a given period, usually annually.  

The following formula is used to calculate this index:  

Inventory Turnover = Cost of Goods Sold / Average Inventory  

A high inventory turnover rate indicates that products are selling quickly and being restocked efficiently, which usually translates to higher profitability. For example, if sales were €30,000 and inventory was €15,000 during the year, the result would be 2, meaning inventory needs to be replenished twice a year.  

The importance of this index lies in several aspects:  

• Management Efficiency: High turnover avoids excess inventory, reducing additional storage, obsolescence, and deterioration costs.  
• Financial Optimization: Frees up capital that would otherwise be tied up in inventory, improving liquidity.  
• Demand Planning: Provides valuable information about product demand.  
• Obsolescence Reduction: Slow turnover increases the likelihood of products becoming obsolete before being sold.  

It’s worth noting that there is no universal ideal index—the optimal value varies by sector and even by product. For fast-moving consumer goods like food, the index should be higher than for custom-made products like furniture.  

Maintaining proper control of this index helps us identify issues like slow-moving inventory—goods with minimal turnover that may remain in storage for long periods, negatively affecting average stock levels.  

Verify Background and Legal Compliance

Legal background verification is a critical phase when establishing business relationships with importers. This preventive due diligence protects us from potential financial penalties and reputational damage that could arise from dealing with problematic or restricted entities.  

Check Restrictive Lists Like OFAC

The U.S. Treasury Department’s Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) issues lists that record individuals and companies flagged for involvement in illicit activities. OFAC’s sanctions search tool uses fuzzy logic to identify potential matches in the Specially Designated Nationals (SDN) List and the Consolidated Sanctions List (Non-SDN).  

This consolidated list includes:  

• Foreign Sanctions Evaders List  
• Sectoral Sanctions Identifications List  
• Foreign Financial Institutions Subject to Sanctions List  
• Non-SDN Palestinian Legislative Council List  
• Menu-Based Sanctions Non-SDN List  
• Non-SDN Communist Chinese Military Companies List  

It’s important to understand that, under the "50% Rule" established in 2008, any entity owned 50% or more by a sanctioned person or entity is also considered blocked, even if not explicitly listed. Additionally, specialized services like LexisNexis Risk Solutions help screen over 1,500 restrictive lists with advanced technology to reduce false positives.  

Review Customs Import Documents

To properly evaluate a potential importer, we must examine their customs documentation. In Argentina, for example, those interested in starting import operations must submit a Criminal Background Certificate issued by the National Recidivism Registry. This document is valid for only 5 administrative business days, highlighting the importance authorities place on recent legal integrity.  

Other essential documents to verify include:  

• Previous customs declarations  
• Certificates of origin  
• Commercial invoices  
• Bills of lading  
• Inspection and authorization records  

These records not only demonstrate regulatory compliance but also facilitate audits and help resolve disputes with customs authorities. On the other hand, incorrect or incomplete documentation can result in delays, fines, or even cargo rejection at customs.  

Customs Compliance History

According to European regulations, compliance history with customs legislation and tax regulations must be assessed by considering the three years prior to any application. During this period, the importer must not have committed serious or repeated violations of customs laws.  

When evaluating compliance history, customs authorities consider:  

• Irregularities and errors as a whole  
• Frequency of non-compliance  
• Whether there was fraudulent intent or negligence  
• Whether the importer voluntarily reported detected errors  
• Measures taken to prevent future errors  

Additionally, it’s relevant to verify if the importer has faced denials, suspensions, or withdrawals of customs authorizations. Although a prior denial doesn’t automatically mean future rejection, it is a red flag that warrants attention.  

Lastly, serious violations include those committed with intent or manifest negligence, as well as acts posing significant risks to protection and security. It is our responsibility to implement a continuous monitoring system for our trading partners, as maintaining relationships with sanctioned entities could expose us to significant penalties and legal issues.  

Evaluate the Importer’s Financial Capacity

The financial strength of an importer determines the future of any international commercial operation. A thorough analysis of their economic health not only reduces risks but also lays the foundation for a lasting and profitable business relationship.  

Payment Capacity and Solvency

To properly assess a potential importer’s solvency, it’s essential to examine their financial statements, liquidity, debt levels, and profitability. This analysis provides a clear picture of their economic strengths, weaknesses, and opportunities.  

The most effective tools for this evaluation include:  

• SWOT analysis applied specifically to financial aspects  
• Financial ratios reflecting the company’s real economic health  
• Business credit reports prepared by specialized firms like Dun & Bradstreet or Experian  

These reports offer a realistic, in-depth view of the company’s payment behavior, significantly reducing the risk of non-payment. Previously, in some countries like Argentina, the Economic and Financial Capacity System (CEF) analyzed financial variables to authorize imports, though it has since been eliminated to facilitate trade.  

Payment History and Bank References

The history of previous transactions is a fundamental indicator of the importer’s credibility. Bank references allow us to confirm their payment behavior with other suppliers, offering a more complete view of their reliability.  

For exporters using Documents against Payment (D/P), the guarantee of receiving payment relies mainly on the importer’s payment capacity and commercial reputation. For this reason, it’s crucial to evaluate the importer’s financial capacity and reputation before proceeding with any transaction.  

Likewise, before establishing Open Account agreements, exhaustive credit checks must be performed, and clear credit terms should be set to mitigate non-payment risk. To verify this information, queries can be made at consulates and commercial offices.  

Exchange Rate Risk and Cash Flow

Exchange rate risk arises when the currency used to finance the import and the currency in which the importer will obtain funds from product sales do not match. To manage this risk, the importer can:  

• Fully assume it  
• Hedge it using financial instruments like Forward Contracts or Currency Options  

A clear example occurs when an importer whose income is in pesos makes purchases in dollars. If the peso depreciates beyond expectations at the time of payment, the committed dollars will cost more than initially budgeted.  

To manage this risk properly, the finance team must define and project cash flow based on the "budgeted dollar," incorporating operating costs and expected capital return. Additionally, it is advisable to:  

• Conduct a market indicator projection analysis  
• Complement with exchange rate hedging products  
• Maintain offshore accounts to provision foreign currency at opportune times  

Healthy cash flow is essential for the survival and growth of any importing business, enabling financial control, risk reduction, and long-term financial goal achievement.  

Review Contracts and Commercial Terms

The contractual framework in an import operation sets the rules of the game between seller and buyer. A detailed review of these agreements prevents misunderstandings and protects both parties’ interests throughout the commercial process.  

Negotiation Terms and Incoterms

Incoterms (International Commercial Terms) are internationally recognized rules that define sellers’ and buyers’ responsibilities in commercial transactions. These terms clearly establish who bears transportation costs and risks, as well as responsibilities for export and import customs procedures.  

As of January 2020, the current Incoterms include 11 terms grouped by transport method and responsibility level. For example, under the term FOB (Free On Board), the seller assumes all local costs up to the port of shipment, while the buyer is responsible for costs from that point onward.  

Key Clauses in Sales Contracts

An international sales contract should contain specific clauses regulating potential contingencies. Among the most important are:  

• Dispute Resolution Clause: Defines whether conflicts will be resolved through international arbitration or national courts.  
• Force Majeure Clause: Exempts parties from compliance in unforeseen events like natural disasters or pandemics.  
• Warranty and Returns Clause: Establishes the process for returns when products don’t meet specifications.  
• Confidentiality Clause: Protects sensitive commercial information shared between parties.  

Accurate product descriptions are fundamental—the buyer may prefer detailed descriptions, while the exporter might favor definitions allowing minor deviations.  

Payment Terms and Guarantees

Payment terms must clearly specify the currency, amount, and accepted methods (bank transfer, letter of credit, etc.). Additionally, bank guarantees serve as financial tools that minimize risks and promote safer transactions.  

Several types of guarantees protect different aspects of the transaction:  

• Payment Guarantee: Ensures the seller receives payment.  
• Performance Guarantee: Protects the buyer if the seller fails to meet obligations.  
• Advance Payment Guarantee: Ensures refunds of advance payments if goods aren’t delivered.  

Surety bonds are also valuable instruments that back the importer against potential supplier breaches.  

Manage Risks and Post-Evaluation Monitoring

Effective risk management makes the difference between successful international operations and costly failures. Even after carefully selecting our importers, the evaluation work must continue throughout the business relationship.  

Risk Matrix per Importer

The risk matrix is a fundamental tool that identifies and classifies potential threats in our operations with each importer. To build it properly, we must:  

1. Identify risks from various sources, including financial factors (exchange rate fluctuations), logistical issues (transport delays), regulatory barriers, and geopolitical risks.  
2. Evaluate each risk based on its likelihood of occurrence and potential impact on the business.  
3. Prioritize the most significant risks to focus our mitigation efforts where it matters most.  

The typical matrix structure includes risk description, potential causes, consequences, impact level, and probability. This systematic organization lets us clearly visualize our greatest vulnerabilities with each importer.  

Contingency Plan for Non-Compliance

A well-defined contingency plan allows us to respond quickly to unforeseen events, minimizing operational and financial impact. This plan should include:  

• Supplier diversification to reduce dependence on a single importer  
• Transport and credit insurance protecting against damages and non-payment  
• Detailed contracts with clearly defined responsibilities and penalties  
• Specific procedures for different non-compliance scenarios  

In the food sector, for example, a cold chain contingency plan must include strategically placed temperature sensors and early alert systems to detect deviations immediately.  

Continuous Monitoring and Periodic Reassessment

Ongoing compliance monitoring is crucial for maintaining healthy business relationships. Competent authorities in EU member states require this monitoring to maintain import authorizations.  

Importer reassessment is necessary when non-compliance, quality failures, or constant complaints from end consumers arise. This practice:  

• Reduces risks associated with the commercial alliance  
• Identifies and manages potential dependence on certain importers  
• Verifies they still meet initial evaluation criteria  

To be effective, this reassessment should be based on parameters like quality, production capacity, delivery times, and contract compliance.  

As part of a comprehensive strategy, we must stay alert and continually evaluate our procedures, updating control measures periodically to align with changing regulations and market conditions.  

Conclusion

A rigorous evaluation of importers is a fundamental pillar for success in international trade. Throughout this practical guide, we’ve analyzed every determining factor to consider before and during our commercial relationships with foreign partners.  

Certainly, defining the ideal importer profile represents the first critical step in establishing fruitful collaborations. This evaluation must be complemented with a thorough analysis of market and product profitability—factors that will determine the financial viability of our operation.  

Likewise, background and legal compliance verification protects us from reputational risks and potential penalties, while financial capacity analysis gives us confidence in our partners’ solvency. A detailed review of contracts and commercial terms, on the other hand, establishes clear rules that prevent future conflicts.  

Risk management through specific matrices and contingency plans allows us to anticipate potential problems—though these mechanisms only work when we implement continuous monitoring of our importers.  

Remember, evaluation doesn’t end after signing the initial contract. Constant follow-up and periodic reassessments ensure lasting, profitable business relationships. Updated information about our trading partners, their practices, and their financial situation is essential to adapt to an increasingly dynamic and complex commercial environment.  

Ultimately, success in importing doesn’t lie solely in finding profitable products but primarily in partnering with reliable importers who share our business vision and consistently meet their commitments. The time invested in this systematic evaluation will always yield positive returns for our internationalization strategy.

‍